Oprhan: First Kill is the rare horror follow-up that’s better than the original – but that’s not saying much | Film reviews | Spokane | Interior of the Pacific Northwest

Click to enlarge

Unfortunately for this prequel, Isabelle Fuhrmann has grown steadily.

Orphan: first murdera prequel to the 2009 horror mystery Orphan, is better than its ancestor. No, scratch this: First murder rather, not so bad like the previous movie. Still, this is a rare and praiseworthy cinematic event, no matter how qualified.

The original 2009 film played like a parody of horror movies, and, alas, not a connoisseur. There was little beyond the genre’s overcooked tropes: the “scary” music, the “threatening” camera angles, the telegraphy of every boo. Its big twist – look away now if you don’t want a 13-year-old horror movie ruined – was that its central “sinister child”, the titular orphan, was not, in fact, a child. 9 years old but actually an adult with a pituitary disorder that left her perpetually childlike in her body. But she didn’t have a childlike mind: cunning and devious, a violent, psychopathic trickster.

Anyway, the secret of the first film is the whole point of First murder, which flashes back to explain how Leena, a 30-year-old murderous criminal incarcerated in Estonia, ends up playing the role of an abandoned American called Esther. Now, the 2009 movie was, at best, a modest hit, and I’m not sure anyone was clamoring for Esther’s backstory. But we can be grateful for small favors: this screenplay (written by David Coggeshall with a story of Orphan writers David Leslie Johnson-McGoldrick and Alex Mace) is more aware of genre cliches this time around and takes advantage of them in ways that offer mild surprises.

First murder takes an unreasonably long time to get around to these surprises, however. If I was the type to jump on a movie halfway through, I would have given up before the things that make this unintriguing come to light. And there are almost insurmountable problems right from the start. On the one hand, Isabelle Fuhrman caused a sensation in 2009 in the role of Esther; Orphan was shot when she was just 10 years old. But she’s back in the role of Esther, 23 at the time of filming, and her character is supposed to be even younger! Director William Brent Bell engages in many tricks with the camera to pretend this normal-sized adult can pass as a prepubescent girl — like using a child surrogate for long shots and then only showing her from behind — and many of them are ridiculously unconvincing. But nothing can hide the fact that Fuhrman’s face is now that of a grown woman. (That’s probably why Esther gives her back to us on the movie poster.) If the very young Fuhrman was compelling as a scary, precocious kid, adult Fuhrman is…just…very obviously an adult with a bit of a pixie face. Is there at least one sly commentary on the infantilization of women in our culture? Ha! It doesn’t even seem to have crossed the mind of the movie.

It’s one of those horror movies where people have to behave very stupidly for something to happen. Security is absurdly lax at the Estonian facility Esther is escaping from, even though they know how cunning and dangerous she is. It’s ridiculously easy for her to impersonate the missing daughter of a wealthy American couple, the Albrights (Julia Stiles and Rossif Sutherland), with a story about how she was kidnapped and trafficked to Eastern Europe. ‘East. (She Googled missing child alerts.) Questions abound: Has anyone thought about getting a DNA test? Wouldn’t there be an alarm from the institution she escaped from, like: Be on the lookout for that kid-like adult, and here’s a pic? How does almost everyone just look past all the red flags even though they recognize Esther is raising? There’s no suspense here at all…until Esther realizes that she has a more complicated family situation than she had anticipated.

What happens with the Albrights explains some of the apparent plot holes in retrospect in a clever way, but also far too off the cuff: a hint that something more happened is needed for this not to happen. not produce. feel like a cheater. Perhaps worse than that, however, is that there’s ultimately no one here to root – or at least be uncannily fascinated by Hannibal Lecter-esque – in First murder. The film does not require viewers to care about anyone or anything that happens to them. ♦

Two stars Orphan: first murder

To classify

Directed by William Brent Bell

With Isabelle Fuhrman, Julia Stiles, Rossif Sutherland

Broadcast on Paramount+

Comments are closed.